Post Message Search Overview RegisterLoginAdmin
Fake Turquoise - Oh My!
Post Reply Edit View All Forum
Posted by: newtoit Post Reply
12/09/2010, 22:02:42

Hi Bead People,
I am a relatively new participant in the "bead world" and know that I have a lot to learn, so please bear with me. I find myself in the very embarrassing position of having sold a beautiful big turquoise bead as "Old Tibetan" when in fact,it is probably some Chinese creation. I assumed it was old Tibetan because I was told it was; now I know that I must research and verify before I sell ANYTHING! I have had a crash course in how to tell real amber from fake, and real coral from fake, but how about turquoise? .... I hesitate to hit with a hammer to see if it is plaster inside! Thanks for your responses in advance!



Copyright 2024
All rights reserved by Bead Collector Network and its users
Two Things
Re: Fake Turquoise - Oh My! -- newtoit Post Reply Edit Forum Where am I?
Posted by: Beadman Post Reply
12/10/2010, 05:26:56

These are very general questions. Have you tried to do a Search of the Archives here?

I moderate four Yahoo Groups, where I also post advice about beads. One is about all sorts of beads, and one is devoted to amber:

http://groups.yahoo.com/group/beadcollectors/

http://tech.groups.yahoo.com/group/amberisforever/

(Links to each Group can be found in the primary Group.)

The PDF I posted in the Amber Group will explain what you can do to test amber and "amber."

Jamey



Modified by Beadman at Fri, Dec 10, 2010, 08:49:44

Copyright 2024
All rights reserved by Bead Collector Network and its users
Coral and Other Stuff
Re: Two Things -- Beadman Post Reply Edit Forum Where am I?
Posted by: Beadman Post Reply
12/10/2010, 09:17:21


Related link: Coral and other useful topics.

Copyright 2024
All rights reserved by Bead Collector Network and its users
Re: Coral and Other Stuff
Re: Coral and Other Stuff -- Beadman Post Reply Edit Forum Where am I?
Posted by: newtoit Post Reply
12/10/2010, 09:19:14

Perfect! Thanks! The internet is full of info, but I like to know who is writing that info!



Copyright 2024
All rights reserved by Bead Collector Network and its users
Another
Re: Coral and Other Stuff -- Beadman Post Reply Edit Forum Where am I?
Posted by: Beadman Post Reply
12/10/2010, 09:43:35


Related link: From 2008.

Copyright 2024
All rights reserved by Bead Collector Network and its users
A L O N G Interesting Series On Coral
Re: Coral and Other Stuff -- Beadman Post Reply Edit Forum Where am I?
Posted by: Beadman Post Reply
12/10/2010, 10:21:35

In case no one remembers, I L O V E coral!


Related link: Yet more from 2008!

Copyright 2024
All rights reserved by Bead Collector Network and its users
Hawaiian Coral
Re: Coral and Other Stuff -- Beadman Post Reply Edit Forum Where am I?
Posted by: Beadman Post Reply
12/10/2010, 10:26:40


Related link: Black and pink coral.

Copyright 2024
All rights reserved by Bead Collector Network and its users
A Long Post On Carnelian Sources and Identifcation
Re: Two Things -- Beadman Post Reply Edit Forum Where am I?
Posted by: Beadman Post Reply
12/10/2010, 10:07:19


Related link: Also from 2008.

Copyright 2024
All rights reserved by Bead Collector Network and its users
Turquoise, Fake Turquoise, And Other Stuff
Re: Two Things -- Beadman Post Reply Edit Forum Where am I?
Posted by: Beadman Post Reply
12/10/2010, 10:15:02


Related link: 2008 was a busy year for IDs.

Copyright 2024
All rights reserved by Bead Collector Network and its users
More Fake Turquoise
Re: Turquoise, Fake Turquoise, And Other Stuff -- Beadman Post Reply Edit Forum Where am I?
Posted by: Beadman Post Reply
12/10/2010, 11:15:22


Related link: More useful discussion.

Copyright 2024
All rights reserved by Bead Collector Network and its users
Stuff from the Tucson Gem & Mineral Show- 2008
Re: Turquoise, Fake Turquoise, And Other Stuff -- Beadman Post Reply Edit Forum Where am I?
Posted by: Beadman Post Reply
12/10/2010, 11:45:18


Related link: Fake turquoise and much more.

Copyright 2024
All rights reserved by Bead Collector Network and its users
Buying and Selling as a new collector
Re: Fake Turquoise - Oh My! -- newtoit Post Reply Edit Forum Where am I?
Posted by: Rosanna Post Reply
12/10/2010, 07:17:25

Hi New-To-It!
I am also relatively new, to collectible beads, but spent many years with my first love, stone beads. My overall advice is to first, join a local bead society if there is one to be had. The members will have a wealth of diverse experience and information to share.

Second, there is no substitute to spending a lot of "face time" with beads. When I was starting out with stone beads, I went to a LOT of shows and spent a long time looking and asking questions. You will have to keep an open mind and accumulate experience and information to apply to your own collection. There is a lot of "suspect" information out there, and it takes patience to get good at something like identifying all the varieties of turquoise, which is a good material to start with because there are so many, as well as so many imitations.

When buying, I decided early on to only make "significant" purchases from sellers that I knew personally, or was referred to by someone I knew. An example would be buying an authentic antique Tibetan piece such as what you mentioned. I would hesitate to buy something like that unless I was really comfortable with the reputation of the seller, since I would not be able to tell the authenticity myself.

For learning more about turquoise, you could start by purchasing a range of turquoise "products" from a dealer like Fire Mountain, so you have examples on hand to compare to other beads as you browse the bead racks at shows.

And of course, this forum is a great place to post questions, although there are limits to what can be determined from photos.

Good luck with your beads and above all, have FUN!



Copyright 2024
All rights reserved by Bead Collector Network and its users
Re: Fake Turquoise - Oh My!
Re: Fake Turquoise - Oh My! -- newtoit Post Reply Edit Forum Where am I?
Posted by: nishedha Post Reply
12/10/2010, 07:33:58

Hi, newtoit,
Would you post a photo of your Turquoise bead, thus enabling us to comment?
Thank you.



Copyright 2024
All rights reserved by Bead Collector Network and its users
Re: Re: Fake Turquoise - Oh My!
Re: Re: Fake Turquoise - Oh My! -- nishedha Post Reply Edit Forum Where am I?
Posted by: newtoit Post Reply
12/10/2010, 09:17:45

Thank you for all the good and kind advice. I have been reading the forum for quite a while and have gotten some very good info ( Thanks Jamey for the amber tutorial). I've been around beads long enough to know that there will always be a question, disagreement, controversy as to how old it is, where it came from etc... but this turquoise was a boneheaded mistake and it made me feel very bad. I will keep learning and reading, I've got a collection of some very fine books from Liu, Picard, Allen etc.. that have been a great help and delight.

Thanks to all!

newtoit!



Copyright 2024
All rights reserved by Bead Collector Network and its users
Fake Turquoise- maybe not fake, just Chinese
Re: Fake Turquoise - Oh My! -- newtoit Post Reply Edit Forum Where am I?
Posted by: birdi Post Reply
12/10/2010, 14:36:57

One thing I'll mention is that Beadman had told us in the past that most turquoise stone known in Tibet was probably actually mined in China, even the older pieces. Tibetans seem to have a cultural dislike of digging into the earth for mining activities. Please correct me if I misquoted you in any way, Jamey.

The turquoise mined in China is very beautiful. It is a very nice stone. It is traded all over the world, as it was long ago traded, into Tibet and elsewhere. It was common for stone to go to India first to be shaped into beads by the established lapidary industry.

Be thankful if it was real turquoise and not one of the endless types of dyed and faked turquoise.

I know you were the seller, and not the buyer, but some of the riskiest items to buy online at the auction site are turquoise, amber, coral, and precious metals. Mis-identification is widespread. I've been a victim. Tiring of returning items, I now avoid certain categories unless I feel very confident with the seller and the photos.



Copyright 2024
All rights reserved by Bead Collector Network and its users
Re: Fake Turquoise - Oh My!
Re: Fake Turquoise - Oh My! -- newtoit Post Reply Edit Forum Where am I?
Posted by: jake@nomaddesign Post Reply
12/12/2010, 21:26:52

I think with most bead identification experience with color is very necessary. for example, I can spot most dyed coral by eye because I am very experienced with the color of natural coral. Though that is getting tough. This example is important regarding almost any historical bead, the chemicals used are different, and the colors of many reproduction beads are incorrect.

Price is also a huge indicator of quality, nice turquoise is expensive. though most consumers either do not know, or do not care about. Regarding turquoise, one of the most important attributes is hardness. Good quality turquoise is hard, and you can feel it when you handle it. Dense, hard turquoise will be warm to the touch under the intense hot lights of a dealers display case. In the same case lower quality turquoise will not be holding the heat because it is not as dense. In converse, high quality in normal ambient temperature will be cool to the touch, and less dense turquoise would be warm.

Stabilization is the coating of turquoise with wax, or some kind of spray on plastic stuff. Some people want their turquoise to be stabilized so as to insure that it will not change color from wear and skin oil. I do not think that stabilization is on its own a bad thing, I think of it as if you were to oil wood. The wood that is lacquered is still wood, it is just protected. It is good to know if your turquoise is stabilized. Though very excellent turquoise does not need protection because it is so hard. Any piece of turquoise can have different hardnesses and could change different colors within the same stone, that is the charm.



Copyright 2024
All rights reserved by Bead Collector Network and its users
Useful turquoise info
Re: Fake Turquoise - Oh My! -- newtoit Post Reply Edit Forum Where am I?
Posted by: beadiste Post Reply
12/12/2010, 21:47:35

The GIA info is in the link, but here's another link to a noted gemologist's site:

http://www.bwsmigel.info/GEOL.115.ESSAYS/Gemology.Turquoise.html


Related link: http://www.gia.edu/research-resources/library/featured-gemstones/turquoise/index.html

Copyright 2024
All rights reserved by Bead Collector Network and its users
Thanks, Chris, those are good links
Re: Useful turquoise info -- beadiste Post Reply Edit Forum Where am I?
Posted by: Russ Nobbs Post Reply
12/14/2010, 00:24:51

I particularly like the Barbara Smigel gemology course.

We will mention those in out forum and blogs.



Copyright 2024
All rights reserved by Bead Collector Network and its users
Do you have photo of the fake turquoise you sold?
Re: Fake Turquoise - Oh My! -- newtoit Post Reply Edit Forum Where am I?
Posted by: redmountain Post Reply
12/12/2010, 22:03:21



Copyright 2024
All rights reserved by Bead Collector Network and its users
Re: Do you have photo of the fake turquoise you sold?
Re: Do you have photo of the fake turquoise you sold? -- redmountain Post Reply Edit Forum Where am I?
Posted by: newtoit Post Reply
12/14/2010, 17:02:44

I don't. It is on the way back to me. When I get it, I'm going to poke it with hot needles etc.... to see just what it is. It could be composite, it could be a nice new stone... Once I get it back I will share more info! Thanks for all the interest, advice and research resources from everyone on this thread!



Copyright 2024
All rights reserved by Bead Collector Network and its users
Turquoise - real, stabilized and imitation
Re: Fake Turquoise - Oh My! -- newtoit Post Reply Edit Forum Where am I?
Posted by: Russ Nobbs Post Reply
12/12/2010, 23:40:17

As the links Jamey posted show, I have a fetish about accurate information about varieties of turquoise as well as the imitations of turquoise. I'll add a few comments here and try to collect all my pictures and post them in a turquoise specific thread.

For several years Fire Mountain Gems mislabeled blue dyed magnesite as "chalk Turquoise" describing it as a real turquoise without the copper. 10 months ago their ask the expert column posted "Chalk turquoise is a form of natural turquoise that has a white chalk-like consistency. It has the same chemical composition as turquoise, only without the copper (it's the copper that causes the blue turquoise color). Chalk turquoise is also a bit softer than regular turquoise. It is dyed pleasing colors and stabilized with resin to produce beads that are hard enough to use in jewelry. Chalk turquoise is considered less valuable than regular turquoise because it does not contain the minerals that create the rich blue and green colors."

Turquoise is a hydrated phosphate of copper, aluminum and often iron. It MUST have copper or it is a different mineral. FMG's description is not accurate.

A google search for "Chalk turquoise is a form of natural turquoise" shows the many sites that quote this inaccurate description.

Dyed magnesite is an imitation turquoise.
I agree with other posters that most "Tibetan" turquoise originated in China. Chinese turquoise comes in many different qualities and colors - some is used natural but most is now stabilized with resin.

The picture below from my Flickr photo pages shows genuine Mexican turquoise in natural and stabilized form. The large piece is natural Mexican turquoise (Competos mine, Sonora) showing the typical pyrite inclusions. This is soft , very light blue turquoise often called "chalk turquoise" that must be stabilized before it is useful in jewelry. The blue nuggets around the rough have been stabilized in plastic resin. In a few cases the resin did not penetrate to the center of the nugget causing the paler center in the cracked open nuggets.

image



Copyright 2024
All rights reserved by Bead Collector Network and its users
THanks for the update on Fire Mt. - I try to be skeptical but it's hard to keep up!
Re: Turquoise - real, stabilized and imitation -- Russ Nobbs Post Reply Edit Forum Where am I?
Posted by: Rosanna Post Reply
12/13/2010, 06:32:26



Copyright 2024
All rights reserved by Bead Collector Network and its users
Update on Fire Mt. - I try to be skeptical but it's hard to keep up!
Re: THanks for the update on Fire Mt. - I try to be skeptical but it's hard to keep up! -- Rosanna Post Reply Edit Forum Where am I?
Posted by: Russ Nobbs Post Reply
12/13/2010, 08:26:53

FMG's main turquoise page no longer includes the text I quoted but it still exists on on their website in other places.
It's a problem in the bead industry when a vendor's inaccurate descriptive name is taken verbatim as the correct name for a mineral.

My own business (Rings & Things) did it recently when we added a green bead with brown markings as the "Afghanistan jade" that the seller called it. It was not the same as the serpentine often called "Afghan jade" but it was very attractive and reasonably priced. On close inspection I discovered that it had a green coating that could be scraped off. The material under the coating was much less green but still had the brown and tan streaks.

We asked the vendor for more info. After a few back and forth emails they agreed it was coated and offered to send some "rough material" from which it was made. The sample of rough arrived - in the form of a strand of tan/off white beads that looked like the calcite sold as carvings in Mexico as "Mexican onyx."

In the case of "chalk turquoise" I fear FMG's buyers and catalog staff accepted the original descriptive name and never reconsidered it until their customers and my posts started to question the name and description.

Ya gotta be skeptical!



Copyright 2024
All rights reserved by Bead Collector Network and its users
To give them credit where it is due
Re: Update on Fire Mt. - I try to be skeptical but it's hard to keep up! -- Russ Nobbs Post Reply Edit Forum Where am I?
Posted by: Russ Nobbs Post Reply
12/14/2010, 00:21:34

FMG does a much better job than many vendors at correctly identifying most enhanced, dyed and imitation stones. They attempt to follow the AGTA guidelines. But they didn't keep up with the chalk turquoise - magnesite issue.



Copyright 2024
All rights reserved by Bead Collector Network and its users
revealing shot!
Re: Turquoise - real, stabilized and imitation -- Russ Nobbs Post Reply Edit Forum Where am I?
Posted by: jj Post Reply
12/13/2010, 19:01:00

Thank you Russ for breaking your beads to further our education.

Didn't realize transformation was so marked following treatment - great to see that & have more appreciation for the stabilizing process.

have posted some images of older turquoise - Chinese in origin I believe untreated.
You can thank my 12 week old Siamese kitten for the broken one..

JJ

turq1.jpg (142.1 KB)  


Copyright 2024
All rights reserved by Bead Collector Network and its users
Dyed Magnesite
Re: Fake Turquoise - Oh My! -- newtoit Post Reply Edit Forum Where am I?
Posted by: Russ Nobbs Post Reply
12/12/2010, 23:45:30

Here is a shot of some of the colors of dyed magnesite from my Flickr pages. This material is often sold as "chalk turquoise," "faux turquoise" or dyed "turquoise without the copper." The black "matrix" is black dye (sometimes simply black shoe polish) tmbled into the crevices of the irregular nuggets.

Turquoise miners and processors refer to soft, pale colored genuine turquoise that must be stabilized for use in jewelry as "chalk turquoise." Some sellers adopted than name for dyed magnesite even though turquoise and magnesite are unrelated minerals.

image



Copyright 2024
All rights reserved by Bead Collector Network and its users
More dyed magnesite
Re: Fake Turquoise - Oh My! -- newtoit Post Reply Edit Forum Where am I?
Posted by: Russ Nobbs Post Reply
12/12/2010, 23:47:32

Crazed white magnesite beads, dyed blue-green magnesite and blue dyed magnesite. The crazing on the large flat and oval beads is particularly nice. My assumption is that the crazing is produced by heating and cooling in a bath of brown or black dye to produce the "matrix" or "spiderweb" lines.

image



Copyright 2024
All rights reserved by Bead Collector Network and its users
Masquerading material and misinformation
Re: More dyed magnesite -- Russ Nobbs Post Reply Edit Forum Where am I?
Posted by: Joyce Post Reply
12/13/2010, 05:52:19

The magnesite that's dyed such a pleasing color, with the interesting crazing, fools people all the time - even stores and dealers. A customer in my workplace was wearing some such beads. A co-worker brought me over to show me "the beautiful turquoise necklace this lady bought on eBay (from a dealer in Thailand) for only 18.00!" I politely informed her that it was dyed magnesite and that this material is also available in hot pink and purple, but she obviously stopped listening with the word "magnesite".



Copyright 2024
All rights reserved by Bead Collector Network and its users
Block - totally man made imitation turquoise
Re: Fake Turquoise - Oh My! -- newtoit Post Reply Edit Forum Where am I?
Posted by: Russ Nobbs Post Reply
12/12/2010, 23:50:59

"Block" is the plastic imitation turquoise that is sometimes referred to as recon turq or reconstituted or reconstructed. It's NOT ground up anything.

The picture shows blocks of man made imitation turquoise seen in a supply shop in Bangkok in 2005. Most of this "block" turquoise was made in the US. Imitation "block" stone is made to look like many different stones including lapis, malachite, rhodonite, sugilite and dyed coral.

image



Copyright 2024
All rights reserved by Bead Collector Network and its users
What Turquoise i sell in my shop
Re: Block - totally man made imitation turquoise -- Russ Nobbs Post Reply Edit Forum Where am I?
Posted by: alipersia Post Reply
12/15/2010, 02:22:50

Hi There
Here are what i have in my shop as iranian low quality Turquoise.blue color is more expencive but becuse of what people do now adays(puting
stone coverd with turquoise blue powder in glue for 20 days)i prefer to
bring and sell green and low quality blue turquoise.
Ali

ΚΥζیΡ۰۰۳۰.jpg ( bytes)  ΚΥζیΡ۰۰۳۱.jpg ( bytes)  


Copyright 2024
All rights reserved by Bead Collector Network and its users
Re: more images
Re: What Turquoise i sell in my shop -- alipersia Post Reply Edit Forum Where am I?
Posted by: alipersia Post Reply
12/15/2010, 02:24:24

ΚΥζیΡ۰۰۳۲.jpg ( bytes)  ΚΥζیΡ۰۰۳۴.jpg ( bytes)  


Copyright 2024
All rights reserved by Bead Collector Network and its users
Re: Re: more images
Re: Re: more images -- alipersia Post Reply Edit Forum Where am I?
Posted by: alipersia Post Reply
12/15/2010, 02:26:46

Sorry i took pics with my mobile phone thats why quality is not good.

ΚΥζیΡ۰۰۳۶.jpg ( bytes)  ΚΥζیΡ۰۰۳۸.jpg ( bytes)  


Copyright 2024
All rights reserved by Bead Collector Network and its users


Forum     Back